Welcome to Gay Nineties Pizza
Founded in the heart of Pleasanton, California, Gay Nineties Pizza brings a nostalgic 90's ambiance to the pizza-loving community. With a menu featuring a variety of Italian dishes, including mouth-watering pizzas, hot sandwiches, appetizers, and salads, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience. Customers rave about the flavorful pizzas, attentive service, and cozy atmosphere. The quirky decor and eclectic charm add to the overall dining experience, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a fun dinner with friends, Gay Nineties Pizza is the perfect choice for a memorable dining experience.
-
288 Main St Pleasanton, CA 94566288 Main St Pleasanton, CA 94566 Hotline: (925) 846-2520
Welcome to Gay Nineties Pizza, a delightful haven for pizza lovers nestled in the heart of Pleasanton, CA. This charming eatery doesn’t merely serve pizza; it offers a nostalgic ambiance reminiscent of simpler times, with decor that transports you back to the vibrant years of the 1990s. Located at 288 Main St, Gay Nineties Pizza is not just a place to eat; it’s a place to relive memories and create new ones.
Patrons rave about the energy that fills the air, combined with the mouthwatering aromas wafting from the kitchen. A standout mention goes to their unique offerings, including the Conner’s Special, prepared with a thoughtful selection of toppings that can be customized to your liking. The pizza features luscious pesto sauce beneath a generous layer of gooey cheese, making each bite a flavorful experience. The spice of jalapeños perfectly complements the cool ranch sauce, a house-made addition that avoids the pitfalls of mass-produced alternatives. The thin crust provides a satisfying crunch, allowing the toppings to shine.
But the delights extend beyond pizza! The menu includes tantalizing appetizers such as Calamari Rings and BBQ Wings, which are perfect for sharing—or for indulging solo. Don’t forget to save room for dessert, where the Homemade Churro Basket promises a sweet finish to your meal with its warm, cinnamon-sugar embrace.
- Customers like Max I. have brightened their days with the friendly service, lovingly described as “amazing” and enthusiastic about the food selection. The team's commitment to customer satisfaction enhances the dining experience—guaranteed to be both quick and delicious!
- Remembering the joyous moments of a bygone era, Regina G. captures the essence of dining at Gay Nineties Pizza, stating how the ambiance brings back cherished memories of dates with her husband. It’s this comforting setting that invites families to relax after a long week, making it a family-friendly destination.
- Fans like Paul L. proclaim it their favorite pizza spot worldwide, illustrating the deep-rooted affection many have for this establishment. The welcoming vibe, paired with an extensive beer and wine selection, ensures that every visit feels special.
In the charming chaos of Gay Nineties Pizza, there's something for everyone—a perfect blend of classic Italian flavors served with a unique twist that beckons you to return. Whether you're dining in or opting for takeout, one visit will likely not be enough to satisfy your cravings for their delicious offerings. I am excited to return and indulge in more of their enticing dishes!
Uh-oh...I hate when I forget a name - Judy or Julie greeted me with an amazing Smile and informed me of all the delicious foods. I ended up adding a Linguine with clam sauce because she guaranteed it would be not only delicious but also quick! She is AMAZING! I am definitely coming back to try out their salads.
I love the ambiance that reminds me of dating my husband in the 1990s. Comforting American foods like pizza, garlic bread, and variety of salads. Cute 90s decor. After a tiring work week my family likes to relax here.
I have traveled all over the world. Maybe because I grew up in Pleasanton but my favorite pizza anywhere is Gay 90'S. It is my #1 Seed
We ordered the Conner's special without garlic, on thin crust, and a side of ranch, for dinner this past Sunday. The restaurant was quirky and had a lot of character, as well as plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. However, we ordered for takeout, and the wait for our pizza was 30 minutes. Staff was patient and prompt in helping us. The pizza was really tasty, the pesto sauce was just a thin layer, but there was ample cheese and toppings, and all of the ingredients added so much flavor, those jalapenos were especially spicy. Went well with the cool ranch I got on the side, I'm a fan of the ranch sauce they serve here (it's definitely not hidden valley, thank goodness). I'm glad we got thin crust cuz that was already a lot of carbs for me, and it tasted good as well, even if on the plain side.
Just had a five star pizza and beer experience here sitting at the bar; my preferred seating location. The small thick crust pizza I ordered was great, with an entire half to take home for a second meal; maybe more. The service was attentive and polite. Draft Beer selection was very good. Love the quirky, eclectic decorations throughout the entire place. Didn't have any, but I noticed they had a pretty good wine selection as well. I will definitely be revisiting this place for more pizza and other menu items which I am anxious to try!!
The atmosphere gives an old school pizza parlor in the 90's vibe. It's a bit dark and not a ton of seating, but good for smaller groups. Their Hawaiian pizza was not lacking toppings or cheese. It was so yummy & that crust was real soft & thick! The staff was very kind and attentive. They weren't too busy when I went, but they were super quick! I will definitely be back when in the area.